newsletter fifteen september 2009
Welcome to our fifteenth newsletter
The other night I woke up at about 4.00am, usually when I am going to bed, knowing for certain that I had made a wrong ingredient call in my latest restaurant review. Despite puzzling for two days in my limited sleep the riddle had been resolved as to why it had been peeled not cut. The orange I had called, I was certain was instead a tangelo! Worse yet I had been reviewing a 22 year old, Brent Kemble–Beech, probably Australia’s, maybe the world’s youngest head chef with real talent! Late in the day I take the cowards option and text him admitting my shame, and it gets worse “no, not a tangelo, a mandarin!” Bloody hell, you would think being 40 years older I might just have had the sense to question the curiosity of the peeling before putting it into the public written word.
About three months ago when Brent Kemble–Beech stepped into the much older and experienced shoes of chef Sarah Turner, there were many, including myself, who doubted that a chef who was just 22 years of age could fill her shoes. After about three weeks in the position he invited me by email to come and criticise his food, give him some honest feedback with the full understanding that there would be no review until he had been there three months. This is not as uncommon request as many might think, but it is a request that rarely receives a positive response. Over the years one learns that honesty, even though asked for is not really what most chefs want to hear. Riding that fine line between being a still practicing chef and restaurant reviewer is a tight rope that often makes me feel sick with fear. Fear that I have the right to criticise, fear that I am not a better chef than those I criticize. Yet I know that it was, and still is, that frank criticism of my own cooking, frequently unwelcome and unsolicited consumer feedback that shaped and refined my own cooking.
Kemble–Beech made me think he really wanted feedback. In another setting, photographed outside of a restaurant environment he could be mistaken for a young Amish, with his beard, clear skin and bright fresh eyes. He looks too clean, too controlled too wholesome to be a chef, especially a young talented chef. One has come to expect disproportionate egos and generally weird behaviour (like master chefs for instance, too daft to understand they haven’t even started their apprenticeships yet) but Kemble–Beech displays none of this read his first Galaxy Guides review
Yes, and for those of you old enough to remember when just four months into my cooking career I thought I knew everything, 33 years later I know I still know nothing. And yes, when that old rascal Primo Caon (Chesser Cellars) will tell you a story that I dragged him from the streets, not knowing he was Italian, telling him I made the best pasta in Adelaide and insisted he ate it, well, I have to admit he’s telling the truth! So, who am I to criticise the confidence of youth? My role now is to encourage the future talent by dragging diners through their doors (and probably giving them generally unwanted criticism)!
Last month we started two new segments hot spots and addictions and both seem to have met with general approval. Apparently the sales of the totally addictive Spanish Ines Rosales biscuits have gone nuts in South Australia and the chefs at Murdock Restaurant in South Australia’s Barossa Valley emailed thanks saying they had had a number of diners come through. The restaurant will be our restaurant review Friday October 9. To go to this month’s hot spots click here

Other publications by Ann Oliver Southern Rocklobster Limited CHEF NEWS focusing on the development of the export market in America and recipe and technique development for the group and weekly restaurant reviews and food for the Independent Weekly —
Ann’s resume can be viewed by clicking here sorry not quite up to date……been a bit busy!
 |
 |
left Brent Kemble–Beech right, his signature quail dish |
The COOKS’S CLUB class program ice cream has run into second class Tuesday November 24 click here to go to the full information including brochure and booking form; the list is kept current on an almost daily basis.
food and/or reviews are now lodged on Galaxy Guides every Friday by end of day (a restaurant day, so more likely midnight than 5.00pm). To enjoy this up to the minute information bookmark the front of Galaxy Guides which will always take you directly to the new articles and recipes on the Galaxy Guides site www.galaxyguides.com
email Ann Oliver
Please bookmark the front of our site and return on a regular basis it helps our statistics! www.galaxyguides.com
and please send a link to all of yours friends and colleagues.
New last month hot spots — has worked well and to be honest we have been surprised at the number of our readers willing to try something new. At Galaxy Guides we remain determined to maintain our aim that punters (the trade name for the general dining public) and restaurateurs will never be allowed to put reviews on Galaxy Guides. The whole process might be attractive to certain sectors of the dining public but we are fairly certain that Galaxy Guides subscribers want a whole lot more. Yet, in saying that, we have come to value tips from industry friends and obsessed diners and have decided to include snippets from people we know and trust. These snippets will add value to existing reviews and for those who love to rush to something new (not our choice) you'll have the opportunity to put your dollars on the table at your own risk and we'll follow through with a review (or not) after their three month opening period has expired. click here for hot spots
Sophie Otten
Australia Gourmet Traveller WINE Sommelier of the Year
Dr Alexandra Burridge
Senior wine editor Galaxy Guides
Sophie Otton has been declared Sommelier of the Year at the Fine Wine Partners/Gourmet Traveller WINE’S 2009 Wine List of the Year Awards. Head Sommelier at the groovy new Rockpool Bar & Grill in Sydney’s CBD, Sophie offers diners what the Chairman of Judges described as a “gargantuan list . . . of incomparable breadth and depth”. This award, the “Judy Hirst Award”, recognizes those whose unique talent and knowledge elevates the public’s appreciation of the role of sommelier.
Anyone dining in Europe’s finest restaurants will have appreciated assistance from a dedicated sommelier in providing information on various wines, their current status as to maturity and drinkability, and their ability to match various dishes on the menu. A good sommelier greatly enhances the dining experience, not only by their educative function but in sourcing wines and assembling a good wine list in the first place.
Top class wine lists, like the one compiled by Sophie Otton at Rockpool Bar & Grill, have the widest possible diversity of wines in style, geographic origin, and market position — the sommelier or chef de cave ensures that all wines are excellent examples of their type, value for money, suited to the restaurant’s menu, and in good condition. This is no job to be delegated to generic restaurant staff! A specialist is required to do justice to the task.
Sophie Otton has been an example of excellence in the wine trade since her first position in the industry in the mid 1990s as a wine and food waiter at Michael Hill-Smith’s iconic Universal Wine Bar in Adelaide. On my many encounters with her excellent service, it was always apparent that she was a woman on her way to the top in the wine world. Her passion and thirst for knowledge regarding all aspects of wine rubbed off on patrons too — and even enticed this writer into a formal study of wine. Universal was a mecca of wine in those days, with its excellent international wine list, its savvy educated staff — it was a hang out for every visiting and local wine identity.
After that grounding, Sophie’s career continued ever upwards through specialist wine retail outlets, wine producers, wine bars and restaurants. Her recent roles have included marketing manager at Two Hands Wines in Barossa, wine buyer for the European group in Melbourne, judging at various Wine Shows, wine writer and reviewer for Gourmet Traveller Wine magazine, and now Head Sommelier at Rockpool Bar & Grill, Sydney.
On my recent visit to Rockpool Sophie’s service was again impressive as she took me on a tour of the very beautiful building, with its incredibly lofty ceilings, beautiful art deco dining room, and unique chandeliers made of wine glasses. We passed the finger-print security into the climate controlled wine storage room into rows and rows of the best wines in the world — La Tache, Rousseau, Chateau Margaux — a virtual who’s who. The depth of the wine list at Rockpool is a delight with two huge tomes, one for red and one for white — pages and pages of gems.
read on |
Sommelier Sophie Otten in the Rockpool Bar & Grill rare wine cellar
image courtesy www.rockpool.com
great web site with fantastic visuals endorsing Alex’s enthusiasm for the entire concept. A fabulous new life for this wonderful building with all it’s squizzy American deco style. A must do when you are next in Sydney!
And yet it is not necessary to spend up big to enjoy the experience because Sophie has selected a huge breadth of excellent wines for a wide range of budgets and occasions.
A quiet achiever, Sophie Otton knows the wine world inside out and her understanding of wine is equal to the best in the country. Congratulations to Sophie, and also to Fine Wine Partners/Gourmet Traveller WINE magazine for their astute judgement in granting this award to such a well deserving winner. Dr Alexandra Burridge
|
october tastings and events
 |
South Australia - the Barossa Slow
traditions & transitions
a barossa Slow event
Thursday October 1 to Sunday October 4, 2009
|
Places still exist for some of these unique events
For immediate booking details, even a spur of the moment on the actual weekend, contact Kath Newland by email kath@newflavour.com.au or telephone +61 434 675 965 Download the brochure by clicking here and visit their web site to make bookings for events www.barossa.comm
The Barossa in the full bloom of Spring, from left roadside shrine and budding vines seemed all the more poignant surrounded by new life, ducklings at Rockford Krondorf Garden and budding vines, a tiny section of the panoramic view from Murdock Restaurant
taken end September 2009.
More than just a great high tea, Sydney’s Victoria Room has lots of fun promotions like
just shucked oysters (a dozen of course) and a glass of Piper-Heidseick $25 read more about the Victoria Room
Hi Ann, I find SYD cafes, bars, pubs etc to be no more expensive than ADL
I cannot remember it being like this when I was younger
even if I have a little more to spend now
i.e. price gap btwn 2 cities has lessened and there is greater range of good beer on tap.
xxx
Philip
ps — view from Shrangri La
bit old school now but it is being renovated in OCT so can't wait to see what they do
but then I guess will be hard to find a table Philip Hopkins,
www.fabads.tv
|
click here to go to the Galaxy Guides Sydney list — more hot spots |

letter from San Francisco
Dear Ann,
The enclosed article about the death of a restaurant is sad but so indicative of our times. It closed for the right reasons, but…… I thought of you when I read it and wondered if the same thing was happening around Oz.
We took Julianna to a restaurant for her birthday this past Sunday which had been reopened amidst a great fanfare called the Larkspur Inn, a few towns south. We’d been there in the early days when it was great, then it went way downhill to emerge as the Tavern at Larkspur Creek. It was a brunch, but that’s OK usually as long as you know before you book. Well the service was excruciatingly slow, the food fair to middlin’ and they didn’t bring two things we ordered. How disappointing is that? Somehow it turned out Ok because the birthday girl was in a good mood. Why do I always think of you in such circumstances? I later read in a review that the service was “professional” What, am I so crazy?
take care, Jan
PS Oh yeah! They were out of nearly everything we first ordered.
Jan Bogart, Navaro, California
To read the article Jan mentions, A restaurant that paid the price, by Samin Nosrat, San Francisco Chronicle, Sunday August 30, 2009 click here
Samin Nosrat, a freelance writer in Oakland, was sous chef at Eccolo (the restaurant she is writing about in the article) for five years and blogs about cooking and writing at ciaosamin.blogspot.com
wine editors
Our wine editors Dr Alexandra Burridge and Duane Coates come with impeccable credentials and contribute their time and advice for the love and passion for their craft. Duane is fully absorbed with vintage for both his own company and the many other companies he consults to. Duane’s wines have consistently won first–rate accolades and have never rated below 90 points
www.coates-wines.com Galaxy Guides Policy
We support our suppliers for their integrity. We need them to care as
much as we do, it makes the food we cook better. buy local
|
|
| this issue
Senior wine editor
Dr Alexandra Burridge celebrates the accomplishments of Australian Sommelier Sophie Otton (Rockpool Bar & Grill, Sydney) read more
Kaaren Palmer, winner of la grand dame de la Champagne, has brilliant Champagne knowledge and excellent general wine knowledge; add to that she us an all round delightfully naughty bad girl who is always fun to go out with, joins the Galaxy Guides contributors with a really interesting review of her recent visit to Mathias Dahlgren at the Grand Hotel, Stockholm, Sweden.
read on
background……awarded his second Michelin star Sweden’s Mathias Dahlgren also entered the S. Pellegrino World’s Top 50 restaurants this year with a meteoric rise from nowhere to number 50.
Still time to go slow in the Barossa Valley this October long weekend read more
the gap, Philip Hopkins notes the closing of the price gap between Adelaide an the Eastern states read more
letter from
San Francisco
Jan Bogart, discerning diner of vast experience, violinist and grammatist read more local and national events for the industry and public read more
the promise of spring
fruit set in suburban Adelaide in our friends’s miraculous little garden
top, bee doing it’s work in the macadamia blossom —, middle more macadamia blossom delicate blossoms that are slightly like elongated lilac but more delicate and with a perfume that is at once exotic and mysterious — bottom apricot set





above — the petit bouchon, sweet succulent and real fast food taking just seconds to cook
click here to go to the Galaxy Guides recipe index
Rockford Steam Powered Dinner
information on Galaxy Guides to go to the information and to view last weekend’s menu click here t +61 8 8563 2720 or email Pam O’Donnell.
Chefs wishing to express an interest in doing a trip and pitting their skills against esse should email their CV to
Brett Lanthois or Pam O’Donnell

restaurant reviewing
for october
A bit of a find in the Barossa thanks to Adrian Bennett, www.rooview.com.au and the kiddies are back at Aquacaf after holidays in France and we're figuring refreshed and revived there is bound to be more than usual pleasure to find in their Spring menu.
reviews and recipes are also published on a weekly basis in the Independent Weekly
|
Want to make a suggestion for food email our food editor
|
Toying with opening a business in Shanghai or Beijing
We know and
trust these people to deliver their promise and all have essential
market knowledge and between them cover all aspects.
Campbell Thompson,
The Wine Republic
David Laris, Laris Creates
Simon Tan, The Wine Centre
Walter Zahner, walternative
Sunday 25th October 2009
2.00 pm till 5.00 pm
Croquet & Croquettes
at Bird in Hand Wines, Woodside, Adelaide Hills, South Australia
Sparkling Pinot Noir on arrival, Afternoon Apertivi (canapés) and a social Croquet match
with Botanic, Sugar and Distill resident DJ Madness aka Tom Cotter
Well crafted and timeless foot tappers with distinguishable head nodding grooves layered with a collage of sophisticated rhythms and a plethora of infectious harmonies.
$35 per person
email Hayley Conolly
www.birdinhand.com.au
|
next month
David Hay, thorn park by the vines, Sevenhill South Australia shares his travel diary — cooking classes in Paris!
more hot spots and events and letters from our friends and much more! |
|
Quality Indonesian Bourbon Vanilla Paste $50AUD 500g contact
Jason Davis 0435 177 036 Australia +61 435 177 036 international
Ann Page (08) 8379 5585 Australia
+61 8 8379 5585 international
Shortly to be on the shelves a new book by a great bird and our good friend Lyndey Milan, you can even do a cooking class with Lyndey and attend the launch click here for more details or just visit her web site to see what she’s up to www.lyndeymilan.com
|